Oatmeal & Rye

Cookies the way your grandmother meant them to taste.

Small-batch, baked by hand, no shortcuts. Pick a box, we bake it fresh, you pick it up warm.

Order a Box

Baked in small batches, every morning

We don't pre-make hundreds of cookies and let them sit. Each batch goes into the oven only a few hours before it reaches your hands, so every bite is soft in the middle and just right at the edges.

Fresh Daily

Real butter, real sugar, real flour

No mixes, no preservatives, nothing you can't pronounce. We use the same pantry staples you'd find in a home kitchen — just more of them, and more care put into each batch.

Honest Ingredients

What's in the oven

A short, honest menu — we'd rather do a few cookies really well than a long list done so-so.

Classic Chocolate Chip

Crisp edges, gooey center, generous with the chocolate. The one most people order first.

Brown Butter Oatmeal

Oats, cinnamon, and butter browned slowly on the stove for a deeper, nutty flavor.

Double Dark Chocolate

Cocoa dough loaded with dark chocolate chunks. Rich, not overly sweet.

Rye & Sea Salt

A touch of rye flour for warmth and depth, finished with flaky salt on top.

Mixed Dozen Box

Can't decide? A box with a bit of everything we're baking that day.

Custom Order

Baking for an event or a gift? Tell us the quantity and flavors and we'll put it together.

How it works

You choose your cookies and a pickup time, we bake them that day, and you come collect them warm from the oven. No frozen dough, no long shelf life — just cookies made close to when you'll eat them.

Orders are prepared fresh in small runs, so flavors can sell out on a given day. We'd rather tell you that honestly than overbake and waste good ingredients.

Ready for a warm box of cookies?

Place your order and we'll have it ready for pickup.

Order Now
Interested in Cookie Shop?
Leave your email and we'll get back to you personally.
built with PeerOne — text your idea to +1 848-458-4020, get a live business